Some People Feel the Rain. Others Just Get Wet

Bob Dylan? Bob Marley? Roger Miller? Donald Freeman? Anonymous?

fallenrain04Dear Quote Investigator: I love the following quote, and have used it on my blog:

Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.

After researching the origin of the saying, it still remains unclear. Two famous musicians named Bob have each been credited: Bob Dylan and Bob Marley. I would like to list the correct source on my blog. Could you examine this question?

Quote Investigator: The earliest evidence located by QI appeared in a newspaper column in December 1973 by Don Freeman who was the “TV-Radio Editor” of The San Diego Union. Freeman was “looking back at 1973″ and presented a series of anecdotes and laugh-lines from the concluding year. He ascribed the saying to Roger Miller [DFRM]:

And there was philosophy from Roger Miller, who noted: “Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.”

The name Roger Miller is somewhat common, but Freeman may have been referring to the country singer and song writer who was known for the hits “King of the Road” and “Dang Me”.

In March 1978 Freeman mentioned the saying in his column again. He must have found it noteworthy, and he repeated the attribution to Miller [DTRM]:

A touch of philosophy from Roger Miller: “Some people feel the rain — others just get wet”

In September 1978 the quote was reprinted as an epigraph in a syndicated newspaper column about a popular card game called “Aces on Bridge” [ICRM]:

“Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.”
— Roger Miller.

Here are additional selected citations in chronological order.

In 1980 the adage was printed as the epigraph for chapter 6 in the book “You Can Negotiate Anything” by Herb Cohen [HCRM]:

Some people feel the rain; others just get wet.
— Roger Miller.

In 1995 a syndicated horoscope column used a variant of the expression. Under the entry for Libra the following was written without attribution [HCWR]:

Certain individuals need reminding that there’s much to be learned from every experience. Some people walk in the rain others just get wet.

In 1999 an article titled “Life’s big picture” was published in an Australian newspaper called the Sunday Tasmanian. The writer Bryan Patterson ascribed the variant quotation about walking in the rain to Roger Miller [BPRM]:

Some people walk in the rain. Others just get wet. _ Roger Miller

In 2007 a Georgia newspaper printed an article titled “ASTERISK*/QUOTABLE” that credited Bob Dylan with the statement under investigation [CLBD]:

“Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.”
Bob Dylan
American singer and songwriter (1941- )

In 2012 a Delaware newspaper article about a music festival straddled between Bob Dylan and Bob Marley [DSBB]:

When asked Friday whether the weather might dampen her Firefly Festival experience, 29-year-old Alison Hylton, of Virginia, responded with a quote from musical scripture: “Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.” The words can be attributed to folk/rock hero Bob Dylan and reggae legend Bob Marley.

In conclusion, QI has not located a direct quotation from Roger Miller during an interview, but QI believes Miller is the most likely coiner of this saying. Evidence pointing to Dylan and Marley only appeared relatively recently and is not strong.

Image Notes Fallen Rain by Wilhelm Kotarbinski, Cropped. Public domain.

(Thanks to Thomas Johansson and Burnéd Shoés who separately sent inquiries about this quotation. QI constructed the question based on these inquiries. Thomas Johansson also found an ascription to Roger Miller.)

[DFRM] 1973 December 21, San Diego Union, Donald Freeman: TV-Radio Editor, Page C-13, Column 1, San Diego, California, (GenealogyBank)

[DTRM] 1978 March 09, San Diego Union, Don Freeman: TV-Radio Editor, Page D-19, Column 1, San Diego, California, (GenealogyBank)

[ICRM] 1978 September 20, Times-Picayune, Aces on Bridge by Ira G. Corn, Section 2: Page 2, [GNB Page 24], New Orleans, Louisiana. (GenealogyBank)

[HCRM] 1980, You Can Negotiate Anything by Herb Cohen, [Chapter 6 epigraph], Page 101, Lyle Stuart Inc., Secaucus, New Jersey. (Verified on paper)

[HCWR] 1995 July 4, Tuscaloosa News, Horoscope, Page 7B, Column 3, Tuscaloosa, Alabama. (Google News Archive)

[BPRM] 1999 June 6, Sunday Tasmanian (Australia), Life’s big picture by Bryan Patterson, Page 19, Tasmania, Australia. (NewsBank Access World News)

[CLBD] 2007 May 24, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer, “ASTERISK*/QUOTABLE”, Page A10, Columbus, Georgia. (NewsBank Access World News)

[DSBB] 2012 July 21, Delaware State News, “Music lovers unite at Firefly – 3-day festival kicks off; Dover site a hit with fans despite soggy weather” by Jamie-Leigh Bissett, Page 1, Dover, Delaware. (NewsBank Access World News)

2 thoughts on “Some People Feel the Rain. Others Just Get Wet

  1. Thank you very much for your help! I love your blog, please keep up your work! I already prepared a (copyright free) blog post in your honor that will be published in the next days -> I hope that this will make more people aware of the importance of reliable sources! All the best, B

Comments are closed.