John Lennon? Roland Orzabal? Nicky Holland? Tears for Fears?
Dear Quote Investigator: The famous songwriter and musician John Lennon has received credit for the following lines:
Love is a promise
Love is a souvenir
Never forgotten, never let it disappear
My mother who is very knowledgeable about the Beatles says that these are not the words of John Lennon. Are these lines from a poem or a song lyric? Would you please explore this topic?
Quote Investigator: In 1989 the British band “Tears for Fears” released the album “The Seeds of Love”. The lines above were written by Roland Orzabal and Nicky Holland for the song “Advice for the Young At Heart”.
Below are additional selected citations in chronological order.
The description of love as a souvenir appeared in a 1961 poem titled “Trinket” published in “The Salt Lake Tribune”. Here is an excerpt: 2
A trinket to keep in your pocket;
My love is a small souvenir,
A keepsake to put in your locket.
In 1989 “The Republic” newspaper of Columbus, Indiana published a column called “Word for Word” that featured song lyrics. On October 9th the paper printed the full lyrics of “Advice for the Young At Heart”; thus, the lines above appeared in a periodical. 3
A 2010 collection of quotations titled “1001 Ways to Be Romantic: More Romantic Than Ever” incorrectly ascribed the words to John Lennon: 4
“Love is a promise, love is a souvenir, once given never forgotten, never let it disappear.”
In conclusion, Roland Orzabal and Nicky Holland should receive credit for the quotation. The ascription to John Lennon is spurious.
Image Notes: Illustration of postcard with hearts from Alexei Hulsov on Pixabay.
(Great thanks to Toan Nguyen whose inquiry led QI to formulate this question and perform this exploration. Nguyen noted the attribution to Lennon and referred to his skeptical “Beatles fanatic mother”. The phrasing of the question above was crafted by QI.)
- YouTube video, Title: Tears For Fears – Advice For The Young At Heart, Uploaded on October 8, 2009, Uploaded by: TearsForFearsVEVO, (Quotation starts at 1 minute 58 seconds of 4 minutes 42 seconds) Song: Advice for the Young At Heart, Authors: Roland Orzabal and Nicky Holland, Album: The Seeds of Love, Group: Tears for Fears. (Accessed YouTube.com on February 17, 2019) link ↩
- 1961 March 16, The Salt Lake Tribune, Trinket by Just “R”, Quote Page 10A, Column 4, Salt Lake City, Utah. (Newspapers_com) ↩
- 1989 October 9, The Republic, Word for Word: Lyrics, Song: Advice for the Young At Heart, Authors: Roland Orzabal and Nicky Holland, Album: The Seeds of Love, Group: Tears for Fears, Quote Page B4, Column 2, Columbus, Indiana. (Newspapers_com) ↩
- 2010, 1001 Ways to Be Romantic: More Romantic Than Ever, Compiled by Gregory J.P Godek, Entry Number: 727, Published by Sourcebooks Casablanca: An Imprint of Sourcebooks Inc., Naperville, Illinois. (Google Books Preview) ↩